From Swamp to Gas Pump – Cattails Take on New Role

August 26, 2009 by  
Filed under Biofuels, Bioremediation, Blog, Fossil Fuels, Front Page, Tax Credits, Wetland

Cattails do far more than just provide beauty in your neighborhood swamp. Photo: Caryn Green

Cattails add beauty to the landscape. Photo: Caryn Green

Cattails are among nature’s most primitive species. They were here when dinosaurs ruled. They kept baby Moses from floating down the Nile to a premature death. They’re ubiquitous, found in ditches the world over. Grown in clean water, they’re edible. Grown in waste water, they remove pollutants from the sewage so it can be safely returned to the natural water cycle. In the process, cattails absorb the atmosphere’s increasingly abundant carbon dioxide to fuel photosynthesis, producing sugars and starches that can be converted easily, cleanly, and cheaply into alcohol used for biofuel.

Biofuels solve the same problems that petroleum fuel creates. Plants use the carbon dioxide they remove from the environment to grow. Harvested and converted to alcohol, they return that same energy when used as fuel. This is why corn has garnered a lot of attention as a source of biofuel.

But corn-for-ethanol is problematic. Land devoted to growing fuel is land that can’t be devoted to growing food. And, unless it’s grown organically, corn is fertilized with materials that pollute our groundwater and contribute to global warming. Gas-powered tractors harvest it; gas-powered vehicles truck it to market. All this for a fuel source that yields – depending on which study you consult — 75 to 200 gallons per acre? There’s got to be a better way.

Whiskey, Biscuits, and Biofuels

Cattails are hard to eradicate and prevent shoreline erosion. Photo: Caryn Green

Cattails are hard to eradicate and prevent shoreline erosion. Photo: Caryn Green

The same characteristics that have earned Typha latifolia some bad PR over the years make the common broad-leaf cattail an excellent candidate for biofuel production: They’re aggressive and invasive. Once established, Typha is pretty tough to evict, making it effective in combating shoreline soil erosion. It is drought- and fire resistant.

Typha is able to thrive in both freshwater and brackish, moderately saline swamplands — out-competing other native species that can only live in one or the other. It’s tolerant of wide fluctuation in climatic conditions and water levels, as evidenced by its occurrence from the sub-Arctic to the tropics, and in areas of persistent drought or frequent flooding.

Cattails are often among the first species to gain a foothold in disturbed environments, even when they were not part of the existing vegetation. They were among the earliest plants to emerge after Mount St. Helens erupted. They’re amazingly prolific, propagating both by airborne seed and underground root growth. They don’t require planting or special treatment; they readily grow on unused land, drinking our garbage.

Ancient civilizations recognized the many uses of cattails: The Romans used them to make whiskey. Cattails were a staple of the Native American diet, and our indigenous populations used them for medicinal purposes, building materials — even to make dolls for the kids. More recently, the cattail’s potential as a food and fuel, building material, and source of paper pulp was cited more than 50 years ago, in a December 1955 Science News article. A New York Times article entitled “Cattail biscuits now” reported, “the starchy inner portion of the cattail rhizome makes an excellent flour”; the piece was dated August 8, 1920.

Bioremediation with Cattails

Cattails purify swampy water. Photo: Caryn Green

Cattails purify swampy water. Photo: Caryn Green

For some time now, cattails have been used to treat secondary sewage (the oxygen-depleted, nitrate-, ammonia-, and bacteria-laden sludge that remains in waste water after solids are removed). In 1986, the city of Arcata, California built one of the world’s first sewage treatment wetland facilities. Today, approximately 500 communities are employing cattails in sewage treatment. Able to absorb solids and detoxify dissolved chemicals like mercury, cattails are ideally suited to the task of bioremediation: They even capture and eat organic bacteria through pores on the lower part of the plant.

But, so far, no community is taking the second step — that of harvesting the plants and converting them to ethanol. A cattail’s starch content would put a potato to shame. Its rhizomes — the stout, horizontal stems that grow just below the soil — can contain anywhere from 40–60 percent starch. There’s no general consensus on cattail ethanol yield — different studies using different methodologies have cited anywhere from 1000 to 2500 gallons per acre — but there is universal agreement that cattails represent enormous potential as a bioremediator and fuel source.

Cattail-for-Ethanol Advocates

David Blume, author of Alcohol Can Be a Gas and founder of the International Institute of Ecological Agriculture, consulted on the Arcata Marsh Project. He has been one of the leading advocates of alcohol fuel since the late 1970s.

“Of the 500 or so municipalities that are using cattails for sewage remediation, none are taking advantage of the cattails to process them into ethanol. The original plans for the cattail marsh in Arcata called for the treatment facility to make fuel from the cattail. And they built a test distillery, but by the time the marsh was up and running, gas prices had dropped and they didn’t follow through.”

Blume suggests one of those “the-problem-is-the-solution” remedies in Alcohol Can Be a Gas. “’How about using the roads to provide the fuel for the cars that use them?” Water gathers around roadsides, allowing runoff filled with toxins like herbicides, oil and antifreeze to be carried for miles downstream. “If each county were to cultivate a 5-foot wide strip of cattail on each side of only 1000 miles of county-maintained roads, boom mowers could shred and harvest up to three crops of cattail per year, producing in theory up to 61 billion gallons of fuel (40% of the U.S gasoline consumption — without using a single acre of farmland while also thoroughly detoxifying road runoff water. Planting energy crops in the nation’s unused median strips along divided highways would generate additional billions of gallons.”

Cattails can treat contaminated ground water and serve as a source for biofuel. Photo: Caryn Green

Cattails can treat contaminated ground water and serve as a source for biofuel. Photo: Caryn Green

Peggy Korth, founder of Sustainable Technology Systems, is a tireless proponent of the cattail as a solution for numerous environmental issues. The author of Small Scale Energy and Fuel Production and the force behind “Cattail Histhings,” a monthly open-source newsletter, Korth — like Blume — has devoted years to the cause. Korth credits her mentor, Dr. David D. Woodbridge of the University of South Florida School of Public Health, with awakening her to the cattail’s enormous potential.

“The American public needs to be educated,” Korth said. “That’s why I’m standing around at county fairs talking to anyone who will listen.” Now that she has “retired” to New Mexico, Korth is only working about 60 hours a week. “Cattail offer a natural solution to multiple environmental concerns,” she says. “It can treat contaminated groundwater without expensive engineered technology. Its starch-rich rhizomes and sugary stalks make it ideal for ethanol production. Its ethanol yield per acre is at the very least three times that of corn, without use of pesticides or fertilizer.”

Korth’s focus is community self-sufficiency and cleaning up farms. She envisions small-scale ethanol distilleries operating in tandem with waste water treatment facilities opposite cattle or produce farms. “If we design it right, we can schedule processing using whatever biomass we have available for fermenting at the time — not only cattail but apples, cherries, sugar beets, or whatever waste produce that’s not selected for consumption — while taking advantage of every bit of alternative fuel we can capture to make the ethanol.”

Growing Awareness, Growing Acceptance

Advocates like Blume and Korth are finding support at all levels — from individuals with home distilleries to municipalities, to legislative bodies, to multinational corporations.

“We’ve been working with Senator Russ Feingold (D-WI) to push forward legislation for small-scale ethanol production,” Blume told Blue Planet Green Living. Feingold introduced an amendment to the Farm Security and Rural Investment Act of 2002 to further the adoption of technologies developed by the Department of Agriculture and to encourage small business partnerships in the development of energy through biorefineries. Blume is also encouraged by the introduction of a bill by Senators Tom Harkin (D-IA) and Richard Lugar (R-IN) that calls for 50 percent of all light-duty vehicles manufactured for sale in the United States to be dual-fuel automobiles by 2011.

Ford Motor Company applauds the work being done by Blume and his people. The automaker has come forward with sponsorship money in support of his efforts. After all, Henry Ford never intended to burn petroleum-based fuel in his internal-combustion engine. His Model T ran on ethanol.

The cattail-for-ethanol movement got a huge boost from Congress last year. Overriding a veto from George W. Bush, they passed the Food, Conservation and Energy Act of 2008. Sponsored by Rep. Collin Peterson (D-MN), the bill called for lower tax credits for ethanol produced from corn and other feedstocks, while establishing a credit for production of biofuels from cellulosic matter, such as growing trees, perennial grasses, and agricultural and municipal waste.

In this context, cattails once again lead the way. Cellulose requires complex chemical processing to be converted into sugars and starches, which are then easily fermented into alcohol, while cattails are ready from the get-go.

Flex-fuel Cars Within Everyone’s Reach

Once all this clean, cool home-grown fuel is available, what will it take to adapt our cars to run on ethanol? Not much. Gasoline-burning vehicles require relatively minor software adjustments to the fuel intake program to be able to burn blended fuel.

“It costs about 50 bucks on the assembly line to convert a car to flex fuel,” Blume said. And the cost to convert an existing auto is only a few hundred. You can buy a kit on Blume’s website.

Blume looks forward to increased public recognition that flex-fuel cars are easily within everyone’s reach. Actress-activist Daryl Hannah is going to have one of the conversion kits installed on 9/28, amid, hopefully, lots of press coverage from outlets that do not typically report on environmental issues. Hannah is an ardent supporter of ethanol as fuel and will be at the forefront of a promotional effort to build public awareness on this issue.

Making Progress

The ubiquitous cattail has the potential to solve multiple=

Peggy Korth’s efforts of the past year are getting a positive reception far beyond the county fairgrounds. Sustainable Technology Systems signed an agreement with Otero County, New Mexico on August 8 to conduct a feasibility study on the use of cattails for ethanol. That same day, Korth received a collection permit from the US Forest Service, allowing her to harvest cattail from nearby Lincoln National Forest and to record the plants’ re-growth. “We only remove very small amounts, so the adjoining stands will invade any empty spot,” she explained.

On August 18, the Tularosa, New Mexico village trustees agreed to issue Korth a permit to use their land and waste water effluent to raise cattail. If the results of the study prove favorable, Tularosa could become the first municipality in the United States to use cattail grown in waste water for commercial ethanol production.

For More Information

International Institute for Ecological Agriculture

Biofuels Wiki

House Committee on Agriculture

Senator Tom Harkin (D-IA)

Ethanol Producer Magazine


Caryn Green

Contributing Writer

Blue Planet Green Living (Home Page)

Related Post


My 5: David Blume, Executive Director, International Institute for Ecological Agriculture

Comments

16 Responses to “From Swamp to Gas Pump – Cattails Take on New Role”

  1. Caryn Green, Contributing Writer : Blue Planet Green Living on August 26th, 2009 7:52 am

    [...] From Swamp to Gas Pump: Cattails Take on New Role Share and Save: [...]

  2. ELLEN BALESTRA on August 26th, 2009 2:48 pm

    I AM VERY IMPRESSED WITH THE ARTICLE.I WAS UNAWARE OF THE HISTORY OF THE CATTAIL AND IT’S POTENTIAL OF BEING A MUCH NEEDED RESOURCE OF ENERGY.I ALWAYS THOUGHT THEY LOOKED LOVELY IN A VASE! THE PHOTOGAPHS THAT ACCOMPANY THE ARTICLE ARE SUITABLE FOR FRAMING!GREAT WORK CUZ

  3. theeharv at 08/26/09 09:19:02 | Toyota Prius on August 26th, 2009 6:21 pm

    [...] Cattails produce clean green fuel! Kewl!http://www.organicgreenandnatural.com/2009/08/26/from-swamp-to-gas-pump-cattails-take-on-new-role/ Posted on Wed 26 Aug 21:19 retweet 0 votes RT @theeharv: Cattails produce clean green fuel! [...]

  4. Anne Russell on August 26th, 2009 7:34 pm

    Amazing only goes so far. . . this piece is priceless!

    How can we have come so far and been moving backward the whole time?

    The Model-T ran on bio-fuel? We just saw one in the Museum of Science and Industry in Chicago a few weeks ago, but I don’t remember that information being in the display. (I’m pretty blind without my glasses, so I may be mistaken.)

    Thanks again BPGL, you keep “discovering” wonderful information that I probably never would have noticed without you. Great job! Keep it up!

  5. From Swamp to Gas Pump – Cattails Take on New Role : Blue Planet … | AvailableGreenEnergy on August 27th, 2009 12:20 am

    [...] Continue reading here: From Swamp to Gas Pump – Cattails Take on New Role : Blue Planet … [...]

  6. Twitter Trackbacks for From Swamp to Gas Pump – Cattails Take on New Role : Blue Planet Green Living [organicgreenandnatural.com] on Topsy.com on August 28th, 2009 5:52 am

    [...] link is being shared on Twitter right now. @theeharv said Cattails for produce clean fuel! KEWL [...]

  7. Caryn Green on August 28th, 2009 8:33 am

    Anne,
    Your positive feedback is very much appreciated. I’m overdue for a visit to the Museum of Science & Industry, I would like to check out the exhibit.

  8. Caryn Green on August 28th, 2009 8:37 am

    Hi El,
    Thank you for being one of the first on the scene to read and comment!

    -c

  9. My 5: David Blume, Executive Director, International Institute for Ecological Agriculture : Blue Planet Green Living on September 22nd, 2009 5:43 pm

    [...] From Swamp to Gas Pump – Cattails Take on New Role Share and Save: [...]

  10. Stephen Klaber on September 23rd, 2009 7:38 am

    Making cattails into fuel is the only way to control them in the long run. Their renewability is terrifying. Cattails, and other aquatic weeds, are a mainspring of the process of desertification. Most of America’s cattail sloughs should be lakes. The cattails in the Lake Chad basin are what’s expanding the Sahara. Making this worldwide problem into the enormous renewable resource it should be is a huge part of the solution. Please try your techniques with other aquatic weeds like phragmites and papyrus reeds, water hyacinth, lettuce and fern. Where I’m working with this, charcoal is the fuel the economy is ready to absorb so charcoal is what we will make at first. We’ll want to move on from there because charcoal has health problems attached. When time and money permits, we’re going to investigate fitness for human consumption with our cattails. It isn’t simple, because Africa really does have lost mines from 5000 years ago or more. There is enough cattail on the African continent to feed everyone there, if all of it were fit for human consumption. As it is, it is a dessication machine, a breeding grounds for pests, and a cause of flooding.

    Thanks for helping make this problem into a resource.

  11. Caryn Green, Contributing Writer : Blue Planet Green Living on November 27th, 2009 9:48 am

    [...] From Swamp to Gas Pump: Cattails Take on New Role [...]

  12. Ken Richardson on September 9th, 2010 2:49 am

    It states that they can be used for secondary sludge, would it be possible for it to tackle the whole issue? I’m sure there are pathogens in the secondary, the same as in the solids. I have heard of some setups on toilets that “whip” up the solids breaking them down into sludge for easier break down. I wonder if this was done with solid breakdown like that, if it would be something the cattails could handle. I wonder what it would take for a enclosed area that could deal with this. I’m sure methane gas would be an issue too.

  13. Julia Wasson on September 15th, 2010 10:03 am

    Hi Ken.
    Thanks for your comment. You raise some interesting issues. Have you considered contacting Dr. Blume or his colleagues at the International Institute for Ecological Agriculture? They could certainly answer your questions or tell you where to find the answers — assuming anyone has done that research.
    Julia

  14. Jim galloway on April 4th, 2011 3:25 pm

    This could save the Everglades from nutrient pollution!

  15. Srilekha YAdav on August 25th, 2011 7:18 pm

    While Typha latifolia grows all over, including in rural areas, it is not advisable to eat as it derives from polluted water as it is used as a bioremediatior, it absorbs pollutants. It is also used for thatching roofs, making children toys such as bows and dolls during the Home Dance, and also used as cap in the dramas. Because of the extensive Typha growth irrigation canals are blocked and the local population has difficulty accessing the river, fishing has become impossible, and health problems arise from still water. In the last few years possibilities have been evaluated to remove the Typha in order to utilise it for charcoal production. Mechanical removal of Typha is costly and is not a sustainable option unless the cost of removal can partly be recovered by selling (energy) products

  16. How to make your own ethanol-free gasoline - Page 3 on December 10th, 2012 4:29 pm

    [...] Cat tails instead of corn From Swamp to Gas Pump – Cattails Take on New Role | Blue Planet Green Living [...]